The Real Cost of Scottish Independence – 2025 Edition
📊 Fiscal Position
According to the GERS 2025 report:
•Revenue Raised: £91.4b
•Public Spending: £117.6b
•Deficit: £26.2b (≈11.7% of GDP)
This deficit is currently absorbed by the UK Treasury. Post-independence, Scotland would need to self-finance this gap through taxation, borrowing, or spending cuts.
________________________________________
💷 Debt Obligations
•UK National Debt: ~£2.7T
•Scotland’s Population Share (≈8.2%): ~£221b
•Annual Interest (at 3%): ~£6.6b
•Likely Credit Rating: BBB or lower
•Interest Premium: +2–3% over UK rates → £8–10b/year
________________________________________
🧓 State Pensions – Day One Responsibility
•Estimated Annual Cost: ~£10b
•Demographic Pressure: Older population profile than rUK
•No UK Treasury Backstop: Must be funded from iScotland’s own revenue
________________________________________
🏦 Currency & Financial Stability
•Sterlingisation: No control over monetary policy or lender of last resort
•Capital Flight Risk: Financial institutions may relocate
•Launching a Scottish Currency: High setup costs, risk of inflation and devaluation
________________________________________
🛒 Cost of Living & Food Inflation
•Estimated Food Inflation: +5–10%
•Drivers:
•Loss of UK-wide procurement scale
•Border frictions
•Currency uncertainty
________________________________________
🧾 Taxation Options
Scotland already has higher income tax rates than rUK:
BandRateUK Equivalent
Starter19%20%
Intermediate21%20%
Higher42%40%
Top48%45%
Other options:
•VAT hike: From 20% to 22% → ~£1.5b
•Corporation Tax: From 25% to 28% → ~£800m
•Wealth Taxes: Low yield, politically sensitive
________________________________________
🧮 Spending Cuts – What’s Left to Trim?
SectorSpend (£b)Notes
Health & Social Care~£19Already under pressure
Education~£9Cuts risk long-term productivity
Social Security~£20Includes disability, housing, child benefits
Pensions~£10PAYG system; demographic pressures
Infrastructure~£4Needed for growth
Defence & Foreign Affairs~£3Would need new institutions
Realistic savings: £2–3b without severe service degradation
________________________________________
📈 Economic Growth – Long-Term Hope, Not Short-Term Fix
•Renewables: Potential export revenue, but needs investment
•Tourism & Whisky: Strong sectors, but not enough to close gap
•EU Membership: Opens markets, but introduces border with rUK
________________________________________
🧩 Summary: The Independence Equation
ComponentImpact
Fiscal Deficit£26.2b
Debt Servicing£8–10b
State Pensions£10b
Food Inflation+5–10%
Tax OptionsLimited without economic harm
Spending CutsPolitically and socially painful
Currency RiskHigh without BoE backing
Capital FlightLikely from Edinburgh
Growth PotentialLong-term only
________________________________________
🔚 Final Thought
Independence is not just a constitutional change — it’s a full-scale economic transformation. Without the UK’s fiscal umbrella, Scotland would face:
•Higher taxes
•Lower services
•More expensive borrowing
•Greater economic volatility
•Immediate pension obligations
The question isn’t can Scotland be independent — it’s how painful the transition would be, and who pays.