The H-1B program was never wanted or needed. It was created in 1990 based on a faulty NSF study that was never made public and falsely predicted a shortage of engineers. Scientists who testified before Congress tore it apart, and even the NSF admitted it was flawed. Yet heavy business lobbying pushed it through anyway.

Nov 3, 2025 · 11:05 PM UTC

Replying to @USTechWorkers
Recently had a job opening for a Python programmer in my department. Management solicited resumes from a recruiter. 75% of the resumes were for people who were living in India less than 5 years ago. Only one was from an actual US citizen. And half those resumes from Indians had no Python experience at all. You can't tell me that 75% of Python programmers looking for work in the US are Indian and that less than 5% are US born. This is just flat out racial discrimination at the recruiting level. They're not even trying to hide the replacement agenda anymore.
6
37
2
392
H1Bs exist based on a study that ignored literally the most basic principles of economics? I wish I could say I'm shocked, or even surprised, but I'm never those things anymore. noshitsherlock.jpg.exe
21
174
Replying to @USTechWorkers
The Indian spy that was caught recently with highly classified pentagon documents- Ashley Tellis - also played a role in advising the American government about increasing visas to India and expediating H1B
Replying to @NeonWhiteCat
Tellis was instrumental in advising the US Gov about Asia Pacific strategies - including stopping sanctions against India (over nuclear testing ) greater relations with India (over China ) and increasing visa to Indians Tellis maintained strong relations with the Indian gov & was a regular on Indian state tv Now he’s being ousted as a spy (RAW agent ?) Why he wasn’t a red flag before this breach is baffling
2
47
1
156
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Mass immigration is always about cheap labor or conquest.
1
11
203
The H-1B program has skewed towards tech jobs even though we have skills shortages in many fields. The program is in need of adjustment but is not our immigration problem. The diversity lottery is a more significant issue along the lines of our abused asylum and refugee systems.
1
6
Replying to @USTechWorkers
“Engineers”.
6
1
127
Replying to @USTechWorkers
The H1-B is, and always has been, corporate welfare
3
110
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Yup.
There was never a STEM shortage in America. In 1987, Peter House wrote a paper that was never published or peer reviewed that "projected" a shortage of 675k STEM graduated over the next 20 years. His method? "House drew an imaginary line from the record high level of science degrees awarded in 1984-86 (the peak of baby boomers graduating) and calculated the difference between that level" and his projected level, based purely on assumptions about the number of college students and the percentage who would pursue STEM degrees. House's methods were highly criticized by mathematicians and economists as politicized "pseudoscience". The paper was widely circulated within Washington for two purposes: 1. NSF lobbied for additional funding 2. ITAA lobbied for the creation of H-1B visas All these years later, the original paper is still not publicly available. When Rep Howard Wolpe (D, Mich) held hearings about the topic, congressional subpoenas revealed members of NSF corresponding with colleagues in academia and industry who were concerned about rising STEM salaries. That was the reason they chose to create buzz about a STEM "shortage", to justify a labor subsidy via changes to immigration law. @amandalouise416 @EricRWeinstein @chamath
9
45
Replying to @USTechWorkers
US tech was an American paradise for generations. Now we are going socialist or at best populist as a country because Tech jobs go to foreigners and just hollow out our middle class and culturally fracture us with imports. GDP goes up but wages stagnate or go down
2
8
43
Replying to @USTechWorkers
I have to wonder how many young Americans were doubtful about studying STEM seeing how many foreigners corporations were importing to fill their demand, at low wages.
2
2
49
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Actual world beating geniuses would still come through on the O-1 Visa anyway. Totally unnecessary, especially when there’s already a housing shortage and we’re dealing with illegal replacement migration.
2
52
The system either needs to be scrapped or completely reformed. I worked in tech for decades. It is a bs system that is now completely out of control.
5
35
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Ohh here is a diabolical evil plan. Lets take the future employment legacy that Americans/americas freedoms made possible and hand it over to India so we can get slightly richer this year Instead of investing in the next generation of Americans. Boycott every company with h-1b
2
8
1
24
US workers are sitting on the sidelines. We have a white collar nightmare on our hands.
2
39
Replying to @USTechWorkers
The American education system was going downhill by 90s ..grades were plummeting. I lived through it. School was a joke compared to other countries. Blame all the studies you want....reality is the entitled attitude had already crept in. Video games were taking over, mtv was taking over....junk food was taking over... The dumbing down of the generation had begun. Perfect entry point for immigrants!
Replying to @USTechWorkers
We need to end it now. Trumps base is being decimated. They are being laid off from their jobs and replaced by H1B Indians. Silicon Valley is now 75% Indian. What's Trump going to do when his entire basis is employed. The democrats base of Indians will be controlling everything.
4
23
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Now think.. why manufacturing went to china and clothing went to south east asia. Yet you all use all those brands and show off. Do yourself a favor, tell your govt to not invest and get your pensions from any company in Asia. Boycott it completely. Get your jobs back.
3
16
In Richmond Virginia there are entire neighborhoods of Indians and their kids flood the schools. It is time to end this visa program. Especially since AI is taking white collar jobs.
2
4
13
Replying to @USTechWorkers
So the last 35 years was based on a damn lie! Who said lying wasn’t profitable, it sure was for these people! No consequences whatsoever from a huge lie that is now threatening the security of the USA! This is tantamount to treason!
1
2
17
Replying to @USTechWorkers
The worst, most incompetent people are making nearly irreversible decisions about the future of the country.
20
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Oh wow, well do cool to know 20 years after that Cozy couldn't get employed as a biochemist because the choice was made to import H1Bs and offer immense tax credits. Thankfully was full scholarship or that'd have hurt the wallet When will we admit they just hate Europeans?
3
11
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Wish an actual journalist would look into what lobbying team made this invasion happen. The indians who tricked our politicians back then deserve an award. They were such a small group in 1990 who had no computers but tricked millions of Americans. Its a bollywood movie
3
7
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Couple decades ago, US & EU GDPs were similar. Now US GDP is about 50% larger due to Tech Majors most benefited by H1-Bs. That said, it’s not perfect - fix it; shutting it down while rest of the world creating similar programs is detrimental to US!!
6
1
1
10
Get paid 1 day after getting funded and daily payouts afterwards
592
805
89
11,831
To push down Americans wages.
1
11
Replying to @USTechWorkers
We were gaslight so corporations could beat down worker wages, get higher profits and increase the value of CEO stock options.
1
3
3
Replying to @USTechWorkers
It was no accident that this false story shows up out of nowhere. Probably it was all part of the plan to replace American workers with cheap labor and they needed to create fear that shortages were in the horizon.
2
5
Replying to @USTechWorkers
No shit all these companies ever always say they have shortage of labor
1
7
Replying to @USTechWorkers
As long as we have a surplus of workers there should be no visas. At all. I remember foreign exchange students in the 80's were also a problem so don't give me the culture exchange motive, either.
1
6
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Microsoft/Bill Gates was a major lobbyist for H1B -1 Visas. No surprise - bill loved getting rich of slave labor
2
3
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Have you seen the Olympiad Team that won Gold Medal for the USA ? 2 chinese,2 Indian,1 russian... Anyway,Good Luck stay in your fool's paradise
3
7
Replying to @USTechWorkers
H1B and similar work and student visas all need to be cancelled and everyone on them needs to return to their homelands.
1
3
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Antiwhites needed the H-1B program to victimize White men. The arguments in favor of it were just pretexts.
5
Replying to @USTechWorkers
Cheaper and more docile labor force, yes. There's also a more sinister reason the Indians were embraced: it coincided with their DEI mandates to basically hire anyone except more White men.
1
3
If studies like the 1990 NSF one shaped 30 years of policy, shouldn’t data transparency be treated as national security?
1
2
Replying to @USTechWorkers
There was always the promise the visa bring temporary not a pathway for citizenship. Also, to help other parts of the world to gain skills to take back home and build up their countries.
1
2