A long-time NYC resident, hard-core centrist Democrat friend’s comments on Mamdani and what his win means (and doesn’t/shouldn’t mean) for the Democratic party:
Adams won with 67% of the vote last time. Even widely unpopular de Blasio won re-election with 66% of the vote in 2017. In 2013, he had 72% of the vote. NYC is a deep-blue town so a Dem winning in this city with barely half (50.4%) of the vote is hardly a mandate or a loud and clear path forward for the party. Rather, that number shows a candidate who has alienated a big part of the base, not widened the tent (though Mamdani probably did widen it generationally… but that just means he turned off even more of the party faithful).
The talking heads trying to paint Mamdani as the future of the Democratic Party will doom the party. Spanberger and Sherrill should be the takeaway from Tuesday night, even if they are less exciting as clickbait, are bad at TikTok, and don’t have a million-dollar smile.
Here’s a hint: the 20%-ish of NYC Dem voters who disappeared did not turn MAGA. It’s easy and popular to say that… but it’s bullshit. We just don’t want to live on either end of the horseshoe.
Good luck to us NYC, we are going to need it. Going from managing 4 people to 300,000+ is quite a leap, and our budget is already in bad shape. The choices are going to be about what to cut, not what to add. People are not going to get a lot of the stuff they voted for. And they will probably get some things they didn’t vote for and won’t like.
As for the antisemitism, I will remember those who consistently gaslit us all election season with constant dismissive posts and quotes from token Jews. It was like if you asked Black people to vote for someone with a Confederate flag in their living room, and then if they objected, you trotted out Tim Scott to tell them racism doesn’t exist in America anymore.
I would love to be proven wrong about this guy. I would love, love, love to be wrong. But I don’t think I will be. NYC won’t fall… I don’t buy that hyperbole. But my bet is it’s going to get very bruised. Again, I hope I’m wrong.
But back to the first point, I’m hoping Dems take the right message from Tuesday night and not the BS I see being spun already by what is a very marginal Dem victory in a deep-blue town.
And by the way, it is totally consistent (and not uncommon) for people like me to be appalled by what is happening in DC and also be appalled by what happened in NYC Tuesday night.