TLDR: OpenAI Atlas > Perplexity Comet in an agent mode head to head.
Here is my use case:
I have a very real, very tedious use case, which is a manual task that I do every day.
1. I go to the school website to look at each of my daughter's classes
2. I look at her grades
3. I look at her assignments, quizzes, all classwork that are due
4. I make a table that keeps track of all of this, which helps keep both of us accountable
I asked both Comet and Atlas to help me with this task, since I have to do a lot of manual clicking, scrolling, reading, and data input.
I scored them based on context (understanding the task), speed (how long it took), task (completing it correctly).
Comet: Understood what I meant, made a few mistakes while clicking around, and seemed to take a while between thinking <> action, did not complete the task correctly (did not populate the table correctly).
Atlas: Understood what I meant, was generally faster between thinking <> action and also did a lot of very human-like exploration of the website (clicked on 'missing assigments' to see if it was a good filter - it wasn't, and self-corrected), and went back to manually clicking through the classes, scrolling, and keeping track of what was on each page. It completed the table flawlessly (on a different page).
Overall I still don't have a ton of agentic web browsing use cases, but it's great to be able to automate this one particular task!