Before going live on CNN, I spoke with young New Yorkers — some who were all-in for Mamdani, others who were more skeptical.
His election night speech landed powerfully for his existing supporters. Unfortunately, it pushed some skeptics further away.
I don’t think it had to be that way. I said on CNN that I thought he had missed an opportunity.
Mamdani’s supporters didn’t appreciate that take very much. I listened and took their reactions very seriously. I talked and texted with several of them.
And I was left wondering: WAS there any way for Mamdani to give a powerful victory speech— staying true to his core values and beliefs, while STILL pulling more people into his movement?
After some research and reflection, it turns out that the answer is YES.
Because Mamdani already DID exactly that — just a few months ago. This summer, when he won the primary against Cuomo, this same leader gave a much warmer, more inclusive and more inviting victory speech.
I would have praised THAT kind of speech to the high heavens - and was prepared to do so.
It’s fascinating how different these speeches are. Here is how they stack up, head to head:
open.substack.com/pub/vanjon…