I used to be a Libertarian until the day the State Supreme Court of Massachusetts granted that gays could form 'civil unions' with all the legal perquisites as marriage, but would not otherwise change family law. The gays refused.
Living without family law was an insane idea, and having the state remain neutral was impossible as long as one side steadfastly refused to be neutral.
'Live and let live' works only if both sides sign on.
In this case, activists demanded all souls affirm and applaud homosex, and publicly grant it the honors and dignities of marriage. Chastity must be grant no more honors than unchastity, normal as abnormal, straight as warped.
But equalizing vice and virtue means abolishing virtue.
Likewise for the First Amendment. The atheists had their chance to live with Christians in mutual peace, and they reject the idea with scorn. They seek our death, and will import any number of criminals, vandals, and jihadists as need to accomplish this, and the god-hating women in their ranks will welcome them.
As a cease-fire among Christian denominations agreeing to never use the government to establish a church, and let each community decide where and how to worship the Christ, and, yes, to tolerate Jewish worship of their odd legalistic God -- the First Amendment was pragmatic and fair.
The cease-fire in the American colonies was the perfect solution to the English problem created by Luther and Calvin and King Henry VIII, namely the evil absurdity of state-run national churches.
But in the postwar years, when the USA mustered little or no resistance to Marxist infiltration, secular nonsense, sexual revolution, drugs, decay, rebellion against all norms -- and, indeed, we damned and condemned McCarthy and use his name as a by-word for witchhunter to this day -- the First Amendment was turned into a weapon against all Christians in the public square.
Only the death cult of secularism was allowed to spread, the sex cult of liberation, the witch cult of feminism, the Moloch cult of abortion.
Only the Marxist religion of vampire jihad by poor against rich, and the promise to loot the wealthy and drink their blood was permitted.
None of these ideas are real. All exist merely to obliterate the virtues they oppose: piety, chastity, modesty, motherhood in women; fortitude and fairmindedness, diligence and dominion in men.
Neutrality is mutual or it is impossible. When it is impossible, we all must choose one. Life or death, food or poison, Christ or hellfire.