A theory behind big brands and franchises is they're supposed to standardize quality and reduce uncertainty for the customer. A Coke in one restaurant is supposed to be like a Coke anywhere else. And yet, there are many videos online of soda connoisseurs blind tasting Coke cups from different chains - McD, CFA, Wendy's - and they consistently nail which is which. You can probably imagine what "McDonald's Coke" tastes like right now. This seems like a failure of the brand to do its basic function, which is to uphold integrity and eliminate any "Coke arbitrage" between points of sale. Indeed, Coca-Cola promotes its own inferior product in the form of the Freestyle machines (seen at Wendy's) which are universally regarded by fans as dispensing the most recognizably terrible Coke of any restaurant. It's so bad I don't understand how at some point product labeling law doesn't intervene and say you can't legally call it Coke. The company seems not to care at all about their reputation in the marketplace. This is more consistent with the behavior of a monopolist, finding the minimum viable Coke machine for every partner they distribute with, rather than a competitive brand trying to win anyone over or set the rules for potentially cheap sellers.
TIL that Coca Cola has an executive who is solely in charge of their relationship with McDonalds

Nov 5, 2025 · 3:18 AM UTC

Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
You've pretty much answered your question already -- it's an inferior product. "Good soda" just isn't their value prop. Coke is inferior. Pepsi wins in blind taste tests. But Coke knows what they're doing, and their own internal testing made this clear to them decades ago. And since they know what they're doing, they immediately tried to fix this, developing and rolling out a new formula that was superior to both. But New Coke was, well...we all know how that one went. They learned the hard way that their job isn't to sell good soda. Their job is to sell brand loyalty, brand recognition, familiarity bias. Making their product more available, more iconic -- more there than any other. The taste? Couldn't matter less.
4
23
The coke vs. pepsi taste tests are, iirc, about first impressions, which pepsi wins from being sweeter, while coke gets more repeat business from being more tolerable over the whole bottle.
3
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
That was Warren Buffett's insight 50 years ago: a century of advertising Coke had granted the Coca Cola company a large amount of near-monopoly power that some management would eventually exploit for the benefit of shareholders, like Warren Buffett.
1
104
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
As far as I know, a freestyle machine coke is supposed to be equal to a store bought, but is worse with being watered down by ice, and that McDonald's Coke is given ~20% extra flavoring syrup, to factor in the ice.
1
10
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
Why the heck would you go to a Coca Cola freestyle machine and get regular Coke? You can literally get any made up soda you want
1
4
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
McDonald’s coke is the best, they put more money into the equipment than other chains. Separate issue, I don’t know what is going on with their cans lately, but they go flat in about 10 minutes. Other brands too, but it’s random. I first noticed it with Costco Coke few years ago
1
3
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
there might not actually be one perfect coca cola. context and market matter.
2
It’s time to take action
2
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
Counterpoint- they were designed by Pininfarina
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
Or, their coke is optimized for the bubble of addiction it's consumed in.
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
The coke syrup every distributor receives is the same. What they do with it from there on out is on them.
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
KO were a monopolist before we both were born. Its a logical result.
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
This is why I never get a Coke at Wendy's, Five Guy's, or Wawa. The freestyle machine is an abomination and should be illegal!
Replying to @AnechoicMedia_
are freestyle machines the fancy soda machines with like 10 different coke zeros and regular coke + cherry/vanilla etc
Read our latest commentaries, find the links in comments:
2
5
0