Personal views. Played Activision games in the early 1980s, worked for Blizzard in the mid 1990s. Contesto en español también. Je réponds en français aussi.

Monaco
Joined March 2010
Japanese patent professionals have reacted to the latest developments surrounding Nintendo's Pokémon game mechanic patents.
‘Striking’ and ‘extremely rare’: Japanese patent community reacts to USPTO Director Squires #Nintendo patent reexamination order ipfray.com/striking-and-extr…
2
4
12
Different potential buyers of WBD's gaming division.
Based on recent reports, Warner Bros. Discovery is indeed exploring a sale to cut costs, with rumors of interest from Netflix, Paramount, Sony, and Microsoft (Xbox's parent). However, I couldn't find a Financial Times article confirming specific talks with Xbox today. It's unverified for now—stay tuned for official updates.
5
1
11
Florian Mueller retweeted
Replying to @TimSweeneyEpic
As an Android user (Google Pixel Pro 9 Fold; remigrated from iOS in 2021), I'm excited. As someone making a productivity app (with a contract developer; not launched yet), I'm thrilled. As an IP & antitrust litigation watcher, I'm amazed.
2
3
37
Many members of the U.S. patent law community are wondering why of all patents USPTO Director Squires took aim at Nintendo's summoning patent. A medical device maker's counsel just thanked me for explaining it was public outrage in games media.
3
8
36
Florian Mueller retweeted
Nintendo's controversial creature capturing and battling patent is now being re-reviewed by the US Patent and Trademark Office due to past claims. gamerant.com/nintendo-pokemo…
1
4
1
11
Florian Mueller retweeted
Following Nintendo's US patent award covering the ability to summon another character and make them battle on the player’s behalf, the US patent office director has ordered a rare re-examination. vgc.news/news/us-patent-offi…
8
29
2
170
Florian Mueller retweeted
The director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office has ordered a reexamination of Nintendo's controversial 'summon character and let it fight' Pokémon patent after it was heavily criticized by IP lawyers. bit.ly/3LIVqXi
79
275
63
2,357
Florian Mueller retweeted
HUGE blow for @Nintendo: head of U.S. patent office takes RARE step to order reexamination of “summon subcharacter and let it fight in 1 of 2 modes” #patent Public outrage, starting with a @games_fray article, must have led the @uspto to take a 2nd look. gamesfray.com/huge-blow-for-…
Florian Mueller retweeted
Nokia won race to Brazilian courthouse against Warner Bros. Discovery by 66 seconds: Rio de Janeiro, not São Paulo, will decide A Rio de Janeiro court accepted Nokia's first infringement action against WBD two seconds after midnight. ipfray.com/nokia-won-race-to…
1
3
Brazil is again a key patent battleground: Warner Bros. Discovery knew that had a lawsuit coming from Nokia, and within less than day responsed with their own Brazilian declaratory-judgment ("court, please say we don't infringe") complaint.
Nokia enforces video streaming patents against Warner Bros. Discovery in U.S., Unified Patent Court, Germany, Brazil; overlaps with Paramount cases WBD has already reacted with a near-instantaneous declaratory-judgment complaint in São Paulo. ipfray.com/nokia-enforces-vi…
1
2
11
Florian Mueller retweeted
#Sony, #Tencent agree to push #LightofMotiram injunction hearing into 2026; meanwhile, Tencent points to multiple Mickey Mouse trademarks Sony's lead counsel can't come to a hearing on Dec 4. because she'll be in NY representing Microsoft against the NYT gamesfray.com/sony-tencent-a…
3
11
If the games industry faces more lawsuits like Nintendo v. Pocketpair, its attitude toward rivals' patent applications could become more similar to that of pharma companies. They oppose potentially harmful patents early (before or right after grant).
Japan Patent Office rejects @Nintendo application relevant to @Palworld_EN dispute, cites games like ARK as prior art after third-party submission Is Pocketpair behind that submission? The timing and the content of the submission suggest so. gamesfray.com/japan-patent-o…
7
36
Florian Mueller retweeted
Amid the Palworld lawsuit, Japan's Patent Office strikes down a related creature-capture patent for Nintendo, dealing a potential blow to the case. gamerant.com/nintendo-palwor…
This is an interesting example of what could have happened to other game makers because of patents on game rules.
Imagine if Ubisoft patented their tower based fast travel system and then sued Sony for patent infringement because Horizon Zero Dawn and Ghost Of Tsushima use it as well. That's essentially what Nintendo seems to be doing to Palworld right now
1
2
33
Florian Mueller retweeted
Nintendo’s patent fight over Palworld has taken a blow, as Japan’s patent office has rejected one “monster capture” patent for lacking originality. Citing older games like ARK and Pokémon GO, it potentially bolsters Pocketpair’s defense. windowscentral.com/gaming/ni…
As I say in that article (in a separate quote), the games industry at large should follow this example and more frequently submit prior art to patent offices to dissuade them from granting stupid game rule patents.
Japan Patent Office rejects @Nintendo application relevant to @Palworld_EN dispute, cites games like ARK as prior art after third-party submission Is Pocketpair behind that submission? The timing and the content of the submission suggest so. gamesfray.com/japan-patent-o…
5
12
46
Florian Mueller retweeted
EXCLUSIVE: lead counsel Justin Nelson of Susman Godfrey on $1.5B Anthropic settlement aifray.com/exclusive-lead-co…
1
1
This is somewhat AI-related (process mining software) and could be a major antitrust fight on U.S. soil between two German companies. Celonis is a "decacorn" from Munich and actually the only major German software company to have been founded since SAP (1972).
Amid transatlantic patent dispute with SAP, Celonis achieves spectacular revival of U.S. antitrust complaint (reminiscent of Federal Trade Commission v. Meta) ipfray.com/amid-transatlanti…
10
The EU can't even agree to do away with obvious insanities like daylight savings time (they just switched to winter time) and the European Parliament's monthly caravan from Brussels to Strasbourg (which runs counter to its climate policies and is generally a wasteful idiocy).
1
16