For a moment, we saw a glimpse of the old Johnny Gargano — the man once called the Heart and Soul of NXT. A man that would not die. And with every bit of punishment he took, that version of Gargano began to reemerge, piece by piece. But before he could fully return, Ilja Dragunov overwhelmed him and scored the victory. Another incredible chapter in the United States Open Challenge series. Even in defeat, every competitor walks away looking better than before. It continues to be the best thing on WWE SmackDown.

Nov 8, 2025 · 1:41 AM UTC

24
249
10
5,512
Johnny Gargano is genuinely one of my favourite talents in the world, purely because of his run in NXT. The DIY/Revival story kept me interested in wrestling for a while, whilst the main roster was as bad as it was. Then the split and feud between DIY really took over I was really happy with Gargano getting that spotlight tonight, and it shows that Triple H still sees them as something special. I’m hoping that within the next two years, we see that rivalry reignited on the main roster, and we can develop Gargano as the companies big underdog babyface, similar to a Rey Mysterio or Bryan Danielson. Whilst Ciampa goes into be that menace heel who always takes things too far, like an ‘09 Orton. Even if it just cooks on the undercard, it’s something that SmackDown could really benefit from, especially if it’s for the US Title That being said, a lot of credit needs to go to Ilja Dragunov. He’s an absolute demon, and his open challenge is one of the best things in WWE right now. He has what a lot of wrestlers of this generation is mission, intensity. That aspect alone reminds me of Kurt Angle. He makes everything feel so or die, everything is important, and it really makes you care about a throwaway match. He’s believable, and that’s a trait that is difficult to learn. What an athlete too, by the way SmackDown gets a lot of flack, and rightfully so in certain areas. Ive don’t think it’s a bad show, we’ve seen bad wrestling before. SmackDown, and even the WWE product itself, it’s still good. But one of my big critiques is how repetitive a lot of the weekly shows have been. We need these mini feuds and undercard guys to have better fleshed out feuds, instead of putting all the pressure on Priest/Black and Cody/Drew. Having them as the main focus naturally draws certain people away. A little spice in the undercard could definitely benefit, and the likes of Gargano, Ciampa, and Ilja could be the guys that elevate the show a lot more again Sorry for the long reply, I have a very bad habit of over typing lmaooo
2
4
84
It’s going good and going strong. Tough stuff 🔥💯
We need a main roster Jonny wrestling run
1
Ciampa getting screwed over is the story in this case.
10/10 hits zero misses in the open challenge 2025 edition
29
Great analysis and fully agree. Hope Johnny & Ilja run it back soon, let Ciampa have his shot first then run it back.
4
the man who always been dead for 2 seconds but immediately came back to life again at 2.99 seconds
235
Is it crazy to me that.. I'm thinking WWE may be looking to dissolve DIY? Using this story to turn Gargano babyface down the road, potentially?
3
94
Give me Johnny Wrestling vs the mad dragon (not Gargano vs Dragunov) in a 20 minute match on a ple and I promise that very likely will be in contention for match of the night
2
I still argue this does nothing for them after the fact. To me this is them not having a creative idea and it becomes a showcase piece. What has Sami's Open challenge done for anybody except dragunov?
The fact that Gargano never headlined Wrestlemania is a shame. He was the next John Cena.
People are writing fan fiction now so they can pretend the booking is good 😭
1
3
They're really making up for the Logan, LA, and Shinsuke reigns huh
Replying to @JustAlyxCentral
A good match apparently but why should I care ?? Where is the story ? I have zero emotional investment. Oh wait that’s only a criticism you have for AEW.
5
8
Once a geek, always a geek.
They're all vanilla midgets that will never draw a fucking dime or one new eyeball to the product. These United States Championship matches are fucking garbage nobody gives a fuck about any of these fucking midgets
Gargano or Ciampa should beat Ija for the title
I like that ur taking about it as if it isn’t all scripted, thank you. the rest of twitter’s wrestling fans are so negative and annoying
Amd the journey is still not over till blocked me on x