Cathal, not the right message. We know scale of investment needed to deliver defence capacity. That’s accepted in Govt, but will take years to deliver. For now we should welcome an openness in Govt to partner with friends in Europe. Our security and EU security depends on it.
I understand the frustration within our DF, of course I do. But now is also a time to reach out internationally for partnership on core defence interests, while planning for a significant increase in our own capacity over time.

Nov 8, 2025 · 7:34 PM UTC

Simon, I recall you announcing the doubling of the ARW, which never happened. That's frustrating. We must defend ourselves, AND reach out internationally for partnership, but at no point in your tenure did you lead the country away from the worship of an undefended neutrality.
1
1
20
Not true Rob. I set up Commission on future of the DF because I knew we needed a dramatic increase in funding & capacity, something I’d been asking for for years. Perhaps now we need to go further but that Commission Report is template for increases in Defence Budgets & Capacity
3
2
2
How long have we had to do this? You were in charge of the DF for a while and oversaw significant cuts and loss of strategic assets. It's not exclusively you fault, but it's your fault nontheless.
1
14
Cathal has a point. I had warned the JCFAT on 9 April 2014 about the need to invest in more robust defence posture. after Russian annexation of Crimea. As I earlier today indicated to Dan Mulhall, its a national imperative ever since independence was achieved over a century ago. The lesson that should be learnt is to have (a) an effective @PresidentIRL behaving like a proper Commander-in-Chief, (b) a smart government that sees investment in adequate defence as an investment in Irish people and facilities, instead of dilapidating our assets to sell-off historic barracks to property developers and still have a growing housing shortage (I warned you about that after Brexit at your “State of the Union” in Gresham; but you were too young to know how we used our barracks to house 10,000 “refugees” from NA after the Bombay Street Belfast pogroms in 1969) and (c) an effective Dáil that ensures government accountability in line with Art. 28.4.1 of Bunreacht na hÉireann. Ireland has FAILED on all three of these, for decades. The response to LOA options pre-Feb 2022 wont keep pace with inflation. The woeful neglect renders us neutered more than neutral. As for the so called triple lock, get rid of it: it is an infringement on our sovereign “neutrality” to enable a P5 veto in a moribund UNSecCouncil.
1
18
These are empty meaningless political statements Simon. Ireland has become the butt of every joke about European security. Total failure.
11
It will take years to build up the capability we need to do all this for ourselves however Simon we should’ve never have had to start… it should’ve been done through the 60’s, 70’s and into the modern day like every other nation
8
Absolutely flabbergasted at your comments Simon. I just can't quite grasp where to start with it. As the French anti aircraft frigate captain will say in a few months time , Absolutment Incroyable !
1
1
17
Explore the possibilitie of creating a joint RAF/AC squadron to protect our airspace.
1
7
We have no choice but to reach out, due to decades of neglect. Perhaps, if the political will existed to address our defence deficiencies, our need to reach out internationally wouldn't be so acute.
1
3
36
Simon, how much time do you think we have? All the indications are that Russia plans an attack in 3-5 years. The 2022 Commission report was obsolete when it was published. Govt should have prioritised and massively funded Defence from 2022. Instead a piecemeal response.
1
20
Simon, with respect, your previous political party was in power for the last 14 years. This entire debacle grew legs on your collective watch, & in your case, on yours specifical as the Minister for Defence between 2014 & 2016 The time for worrying about messaging is long past
14
Simon as a former minister of defence you would potentially have had to send our people into harms way with inferior outdated equipment. We’ve had a generation of underfunding and neglect. And at the heart of that is the DOD who are not fit for purpose.
2
1
18
This is incredibly disingenuous from @simoncoveney Part of a govt that refused to send weapons to Ukraine, but is happy to have a French frigate sit in Dublin to offer air defence under the guise of “partnership”. We see you Coveney
10
Let's hope we have the time, but hope may not be enough . Immediate action was required over 4 years ago. 🇮🇪
12
Simon Ireland’s senior politicians have failed to think & act strategically. Now is the time to start doing so at least on Defence (core elements missing), Health & Housing (3 decades of dysfunctionality). You still have profile & are engaged.
1
10
Over time?Simo,you knew about every single one of these issues when you were minister. You did nothing. Now somehow you want us to rely on "partnership" due to this governments lack of accountability in defence?Why isn't Jacqui McCrum being called to account for incompetence?
1
17
Where is the ARW new headquarters in Kildare and the military medical facility in baldonnel neither are under construction?
2
Years to deliver. Off course, so more people leave the DF so the state does not have to spend, it can all be done immediately with the will of DPER and the Department Of Finance
1
A few weeks ago in the budget there was a 2 billion increase in welfare and 150 million for defence kinda sums up Irelands priorities
1
You stood up in Dail Eireann a few years ago as Minister For Defence (Offence) and said our geographical position protects us 🙄
1
Planning for an increase, just planning not implementation
We don't have a full time minister for defence a standalone minister for defence ,that can be done immediately but won't be,primary radar was in the Commission report from 2022 and should have been purchased in 2023
Should have invested years ago. No one cared or listened when investment was needed in the past. Shame on FF and FG. Your inaction has left us in this situation. All talk! Fast track investment now.
1
10
Over 50 FURTHER premature deaths of serving & former #IrishAirCorps personnel since I made a protected disclosure to you almost a decade ago in December 2015 Some of those deaths could have been prevented. I thought you would help but you never did Zero interventions #115dead
1
Simon, how many people are dying on hospital trolleys tonight?
Sorry Simon if you spent the money on the salary and on the equipment we be not the dads army of the eu.
3
Mr. Coveney, reaching out is outsourcing. You were Minister for Defence. Have you no shame? You have no right to comment on this fiasco.
1
8
Partnership is for equals. What you and your government have done is make us beggars.
1