Let’s strip away every layer of China’s false narrative:
1. “Illegally grounded warship” — Wrong. The BRP Sierra Madre has been stationed at Ayungin Shoal since 1999. Ayungin is inside the Philippines’ 200-nautical-mile EEZ under UNCLOS. That makes it Philippine territory to defend and patrol. No illegality exists when a sovereign state stations its own vessel on its own seabed.
2. “Ren’ai Jiao is China’s territory” — Wrong again. The 2016 Hague Tribunal ruling explicitly declared that China’s so-called “historic rights” and its Nine-Dash Line have no legal basis in international law. Every major power, ASEAN partners, the EU, and the UN Secretary General have acknowledged this ruling. The only country denying it is China itself.
3. “Philippine boats ignored clear warnings” — China has no authority to issue warnings in another nation’s EEZ. Under UNCLOS, only the Philippines has the right to regulate, police, and manage Ayungin Shoal and its waters. China’s “warnings” are nothing more than unlawful harassment.
4. “CCG was conducting normal law enforcement” — False. Law enforcement applies only within a country’s sovereign territory. China’s CCG operations inside the West Philippine Sea are acts of trespass and coercion. Harassing supply boats, blocking access, and firing water cannons at lawful missions is not “law enforcement”—it is bullying.
5. “Legitimate and lawful operations” — On the contrary, what is legitimate and lawful is the Philippines resupplying its outpost and protecting its fishermen within its EEZ. China’s presence is the illegal one, a direct violation of both UNCLOS and its own commitment to the 2002 ASEAN–China Declaration on the Conduct of Parties (DOC), which calls for self-restraint.
FOR CLEAR UNDERSTANDING:
Ayungin Shoal is Philippine territory by law, by right, and by geography. The BRP Sierra Madre is a symbol of lawful sovereignty. Every Chinese ship that enters these waters trespasses, bullies, and violates international law. No propaganda, no “historic map,” and no staged press release can change that reality.
Recently, the Philippines' illegally grounded warship at Ren'ai Jiao released two small boats which, ignoring China's repeated clear warnings, approached Chinese coast guard vessels conducting normal law-enforcement operations in an unprofessional and dangerous manner. Chinese coast guard vessels took control measures against the Philippine vessels in accordance with laws and regulations, and the operations were legitimate and lawful, Gan Yu, spokesperson for the China Coast Guard, said in a statement on Friday.