i’m trying my best to summarize my dislike of 3d printing because it comes in waves. it boils down to: it’s not a serious process because of simple physics
on one hand, it is a deeply useful technology for non-structural prototyping. but so are hammers and neither are revolutionary enough to “bring manufacturing back to the united states”
it’s anisotropic. e.g. you can’t analyze it to determine requisite part strength against things like yield or ultimate stress
it’s slow - andrew mccallip showed you can CNC parts faster than 3d printing them recently (link below)
it’s susceptible to cold flow (creep) in a way that makes injection molding look like 4340
the unit economics never make sense past onesie-twosies, even if the physical properties weren’t a blocker
it isn’t water tight (i mean, come on)
but my biggest complaint is that it inspires lazy thinking. we live in the most exciting time ever for manufacturing. i can click a buy button on a site like sendcutsend and get production grade aluminum or steel parts in days
note that i didn’t complain about strength - that’s the least of its problems
anyways, to summarize, get better at mechanical design and design with real materials so we can truly reindustrialize. thanks for coming to my ted talk
Whether you know it or not, 3D printing is going to be an essential part of bringing manufacturing back to the United States. Join or Die.